The Presbyterians in Raymond organized as early as 1842 but the first church building was not erected until 1868.

Membership was very small during the formative years. In 1902, a fire seriously damaged the church and burned all of the valuable church records. The sanctuary was remodeled in 1913.

Today, the Presbyterian Church is noted for its simple beauty as well as its stained glass windows. Many of the windows are in memory of church members who have passed away.